Currently reading "Sold" by Patricia Cormick, Lakshmi is brought into the city to "work' for her new Auntie Bimla. Her imagination of the city brings her disappointing news. There are no gold roofs. All they are made out of are just metal. She is astonished by the sights she sees though, men with little devices that they talk into to, a phone, and she sees many pictures of women, all beautiful and glossed up, looking like movie stars. She is later brought into a different part of the city, a section where it seems a lot like her hometown, Nepali. Lakshmi makes a choice that changes her feelings about the city.
Lakshmi, a Nepali girl who knows nothing about being in the city is brought into it. Lakshmi's innocence, her not knowing what working in the city really means sort of helps her along the way. At first she thought that the city was a good place to be. A place where all the roofs of house are made out of gold. And when she is brung into the city, she thought going to be a maid, when really she was sold into prostitution. For example on page 105, Lakshmi says to a girl who lives in the same house as she does, "There is a mistake, I'm here to work as a maid for a rich lady." This is saying that Lakshmi believed what Auntie Bimla told her. Her innocence betrays her and she falls into a pit where she can no longer escape.
As the story continues on, Lakshmi is slowly introduced to reality. Her friend, Shahanna explains to her why the other girls are here. She then realizes that she has to stay in the "home" she's in in order to sent her wages home to her family. This is the decision she makes that changes her way of thinking. She knows that the "thing" she's doing is a disgraceful thing. For example on page 116, she says, "Inside I am begging her not to go, not to leave me alone watching the world go by outside my locked-in room. But on the outside I am blank. I have already learned from these city people. From the ones who turned a blind eye to the legless beggar boy, from the ones who shuffle through this city of the dead with their eyes empty. You are safe here only if you do not show how frightened you are." This is showing how she now understands how the city works. You don't say anything and you will be left alone like all the other girls.
Lakshmi makes her choice by considering the following factors; her family and herself. She has to understand that that not all the good things in life happen to good people. She must think about her decisions before running away from them and returning to her Ama for safety.
I really agree with how you said "not all the good things in life happen to good people". Its pretty unfortunate really, the fact that MANY good things happen to those who don't really deserve it although I'm not sure what makes one deserve good or bad. Either way, it is still very true that sometimes choices can seem so simple and innocent but once you choose, it unveals a whole monsterous web of problems waiting to strangle those who fall in it.
ReplyDeleteI really like your part about innocence. You said that her innocence caused her to fall into a pit, but her innocence also helped her so much along the way. Innocence is really interesting. It can be so helpful when you want to pretend that everything's going to be fine. However, that safety net of innocence can fall a way without notice and leave you in reality, just then realizing how hard life is.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed this post. You used tons of text details to support your idea. I also agree how at the end you say, "Not all the good things in life happen to good people." It's very true, and sad that good people have things happen to them that should not happen. I also agree with Talia when she mentioned that innocence is interesting. Good post!
ReplyDeleteI agree with Talia and what you mentioned about Lakshmi's innocence. At first it seemed to help her but in the end it seemed to make verything harder for Lakshmi. I think since it took so long for her to figure out what was really happening to her, she is still overwhelmed by the truth that she is locked away from the world with a burden on her back and no way to escape. Great post!!
ReplyDeleteI really liked this post because I agree with your thoughts and they're fully backed up with details. And it's not overly explained too! It made me actually interested other than just reading a post that I have to post on comment on for hw. I like how you put that not all good things in life happen to good people. And how she has to think about her decisions. But I guess it's also not fair in a way that she had no idea! Being poor almost hid her from the reality of things!
ReplyDelete